The current members are vocalist Adam Lazzara, guitarist/back-up vocalist Matthew Fazzi, guitarist Eddie Reyes, drummer Mark O'Connell, and bassist/back-up vocalist Matt Rubano.The band released their latest album, New Again, on June 2, 2009.
Taking Back Sunday released the following albums including Tell All Your Friends (2002), Where You Want To Be (2004), Strung Out on Taking Back Sunday String Quartet T (2006), Louder Now (2006), Makedamnsure Pt.1 (2006), Makedamnsure Pt.2 (2006), Twenty Twenty Surgery, Pt. 2 (2006), Twenty Twenty Surgery (2006), Liar Pt 2 (2006), Liar (It Takes on to Know One) Pt 1 (2006), Louder Now DVD: Partone (2006), Notes from the Past (2007), Louder Now: Part Two (2007), New Again (2009) and Live From Orensanz (2010).
- You Know How I Do
- Bike Scene
- Cute Without the 'E' (Cut From the Team)
- There's No 'I ' In Team
- Great Romances of the 20th Century
- Ghost Man on Third
- Timberwolves At New Jersey
- The Blue Channel
- You're So Last Summer
- Head Club
- Cute Without The 'e' (Cut From The Team)
- This Photograph Is Proof (I Know You Know)
- You Know How I Do
- One-Eighty By Summer
- Number Five With A Bullet
- You're So Last Summer
- A Decade Under The Influence
- New American Classic
- Ghost Man On Third
- Little Devotional
- Set Phasers To Stun
- You're Good News (To Me) (Original Composition)
- What It Feels Like To Be A Ghost
- Liar (It Takes One To Know One)
- MakeDamnSure
- Up Against (Blackout)
- My Blue Heaven
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery
- Spin
- Divine Intervention
- Miami
- Error Operator
- I'll Let You Live
Makedamnsure Pt.1
- Makedamnsure
- Sleep
Makedamnsure Pt.2
- Makedamnsure
- What's It Feel Like To Be A Ghost? (Live)
- Error: Operator (Live)
- Makedamnsure (Video)
Twenty Twenty Surgery, Pt. 2
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery
- Divine Intervention [Acoustic][Live]
Twenty Twenty Surgery
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery
- Brooklyn (Bonus Track)
Liar (It Takes on to Know One) Pt 1
- Liar (It Takes On To Know One)
- Spin (Live)
- What's It Feels Like To Be A Ghost?
- Liar (It Takes One To Know One)
- MakeDamnSure
- Up Against (Blackout)
- My Blue Heaven
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery
- Spin
- Divine Intervention
- Miami
- Error: Operator
- I'll Let You Live
- Liar (It Takes One To Know One) (Live)
- MakeDamnSure (Live)
- Error: Operator (Live)
- Divine Intervention (Live)
- You Know How I Do
- You're So Last Summer
- Ghost Man On Third
- Cute Without The "E" [Cut From The Team]
- A Decade Under The Influence
- Bonus Most PT. II
- This Photograph Is Proof [I Know You Know]
- Number Five With A Bullet
- One Eighty Summer
- ...Slowdance On The Inside
- The Ballad Of Sal Villanueva
- Your Own Disaster '04
- What’s It Feel Like To Be A Ghost?
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery
- My Blue Heaven
- Spin
- Liar (It Takes One To Know One)
- MakeDamnSure
- Error: Operator
- Divine Intervention
- Sleep
- Brooklyn (If You See Something,Say Something)
- What’s It Feel Like To Be A Ghost? (live performance) (DVD)
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery (live performance) (DVD)
- My Blue Heaven (live performance) (DVD)
- Spin (live performance) (DVD)
- Twenty-Twenty Surgery (video) (DVD)
- Liar (It Takes One To Know One) (video/making of the Video) (DVD)
- 12 Days Of Christmas: Christmas Is For The Birds (animation) (DVD)
New Again
- New Again
- Sink Into Me
- Lonely, Lonely
- Summer, Man
- Swing
- Where My Mouth Is
- Cut Me Up Jenny
- Catholic Knees
- Capital M-E
- Carpathia
- Everything Must Go
Live From Orensanz
- MakeDamnSure (Live From Orensanz)
- New Again (Live From Orensanz)
- A Decade Under The Influence/Lightning Song (Live From Orensanz)
- One-Eighty By Summer (Live From Orensanz)
- Your Own Disaster (Live From Orensanz)
- My Blue Heaven (Live From Orensanz)
- Carpathia (Live From Orensanz)
- Didn't See That Coming (Live From Orensanz)
- Set Phasers To Stun (Live From Orensanz)
- Everything Must Go (Live From Orensanz)
- Cute Without The 'E' (Cut From The Team) [Live From Orensanz]
- Post Shave Healer
- Title Unknown
- Bonus Mosh Pt.II
- What's It Feel Like to Be a Ghost?
- Up Against (Blackout)
- Beautiful Girl
- You're My Angel
- Bonus Mosh Pt. 2
- One Way Conversation
- Go On
- I'm Not Gay (I Just Wish I Were)
- Bonus Moshpit Part 2
- Brooklyn (If You See Something, Say Something)
- Eleven
- Falling For You
- False Hope (Before I Go)
- Follow The Format
- Good Enough
- Just Like Heaven
- Lullaby
- Message In A Bottle
- Mutual Head Club
- Cute Without the 'E' (Cut From the Team)
- Lost And Found
- Hold Me Tonight
- The Things We'll Never Know
- This Photograph Is Proof (I Know You Know)
- Summer Stars
- Cute Without
- Suburban Home / I Like Food
- Devine Intervention
- Liar (It Takes One To Know One)